Hi @Naina I use to use the Garnier one too, try the KIEHLS midnight recovery cleansing oil, it removes makeup really well and is gentle on the skin. Also if you would like to see a review about it I out one up a while ago.
the second option would be the Elemis cleansing balm.
@Naina I am currently using UD Meltdown Makeup Remover Dissolving Spray and everything comes off in one swipe, and I’m talking heavy night out eye makeup!! Love it so much, I decided to try the smaller travel size bottle just to see if it was worth the money and definitely think it is! Definitely recommend.
@Naina When it comes to eyes one has to very careful as they are very sensitive . Coconut oil is a good makeup remover if it suits your skin !! Not sure if it use for eye but being chemical free it should be most suitable
I agree with @Michele82 , the Elemis Cleansing balm is great for removing any makeup including waterproof mascara. I can also recommend Gatineau Floracil eye makeup remover, it's a great gentle and effective one @Naina .