Have you tried Clinique's Beyond Perfecting Super Concealer? I had tried all sorts that never seemed to work! My eyes are always watery so I'd end up with no make up under my eyes. The Super Concealer does stay on as it's waterproof. Love it!
I use either tarts or Charlotte tilbury, I’d recommend not going to light under your eyes as this can age you, also blend it with a beauty blender and set with a no colour powder. Try not to smile or more your face whilst your doing the powder 👍🏻😄 x
Charlotte Tilbury have just released the MAGIC AWAY liquid concealer. Just dab a couple of blobs on the underneath of your eyes and tap in with your fingers. A sponge tends to take off all the product so best to use your finger to do this. Also, NO POWDER.. it's really ageing and seems to settle in all the creases and lines and looks "caked on" in a short time. I'm in my early sixty's so I'm speaking from years of trial and error :-D Hope this helps ... LS1810xxx
My favourite product is the urban decay naked skin concealer. Find this cover’s everything, and is not heavy under your eyes. This product is also super hydrated, and not cakey. Also I find it dose not emphasis your lines and it’s my go to concealer. My skin is dry and sensitive, and this works wonders.